“I defended myself with all the passion I could summon. I was ready to do anything except give in; my happiness and life were at stake” (pg. 90)
These passages from Emilie Carles’ book A Life of Her Own were really interesting in regards to how similar and different they were to the other readings we have had. Looking at her relationship with her family, along with her betrothed-turned-husband Jean Carles, was interesting because it is very reminiscent of Simone de Beauvoir’s novel The Prime of Life. They both share similar sentiments with their respective families; they both talk about them in great detail, but they don’t follow what they want them to do. For Emilie, her entire family is adamantly opposed to her marrying Jean Carles because they consider him to be a “harem-chaser”, “good-for-nothing”, and that he is of a lower status (pg. 90). They say they know best and that she should (and would) follow their advice against him. Everyone, including Jean’s overbearing and emotionally incestuous mother, is telling her to not marry him, but in the end, she does. This correlates to de Beauvoir in the sense that her family didn’t want her to marry philosopher Jean-Paul Satre because it was damaging to their prestigious reputation. Their marriages also turn out similarly. Before de Beauvoir got married to Satre, she lived an independent life in Paris. However, once she and Satre started courting/got married, she assumed a lot of his beliefs/opinions, regarding them as her own. Their marriage became open, which followed de Beauvoir’s beliefs in dismantling tradition, but it did compromise her beliefs in women’s independence from the reliance on men. Similarly, Carles suffered a similar fate. She lived as independently as she could, but Jean Carles roped her in enough to think that they could build a life together and be equally yoked whenever it came to it. That didn’t end up happening; Emilie was the one being the adult in the relationship. She had to keep money away so Jean wouldn’t frivolously spend it, she took care of their children, paid the bills, etc. Instead of helping her, Jean just called her their “ant”, which is in reference to the story of the ant and the grasshopper which talks about the ant being prepared while the grasshopper is lazy/doesn’t think ahead. Carles and de Beauvoir were women of insight, intelligence, and were ahead of their time. However, we see that the similarities of their lives (social/familial expectations and men’s failure to commit/do the needful) are what caused them to microscopically compromise themselves/their beliefs.
I agree with what you wrote, I noticed the same things when I read this work as well. I took a little different approach with my post but it was really interesting to read about this.
ReplyDelete