“Her heart is in the right place.” (pg. 196)
The fiery nature of this piece speaks volumes of what it meant to be Irish during Devlin’s time, but it also shows what it means to really stand for something. Devlin’s defiance through this part of her story ranging from her and her friends trying to make St. Patrick’s Academy more than just a poor grammar school to her calling Mother Benignus a bigot is what the story is all about. However, it does challenge the essence of right and wrong.
These girls, specifically Devlin herself, grew up in a war torn country that was filled with hate (some of it for the right reasons). They grew up in a place that didn’t value their education, as seen by the government not funding their schools. With this being said, their defiance, fervor, and intellect got them to the point where they could fend for themselves and think for themselves. While the people in their lives did support this somewhat, some of their ideas/doings were seen as disrespectful. For example, Devlin respected Mother Benignus and referenced her as “the most charitable person” she knew (pg. 196). She didn’t charge the less fortunate for their education coupled with her obstinance for the Ministry of Education taking away their Irish history books because they were published in Southern Ireland and were considered “sedition and treason in the name of history” (pg. 190). However, Mother Benignus was extremely anti-England and refused to have anything to do with the English. It was to the point that she ripped down a visual aid that helped students understand history just because some of the people represented on it were of English descent. This is where the question becomes, where do you draw the line in terms of defiance?
Devlin defies Mother Benignus’ anti-Anglo pro-Irish tendencies, but also Mother Benignus defies her own government in regards to their children’s education. Was Devlin right in calling Mother Benignus a bigot? Where can that line of right and wrong be drawn? Can they both be right?
I really like what you wrote. I like how you asked questions at the end and made me think and answer those questions.
ReplyDelete